The Pros and Cons of Extruded Gutters: Your Go-To Guide for Homeowners 

Gutters may not be the most glamorous part of your home, but they play a crucial role in protecting it. They direct rainwater away from your roof, walls, and foundation, helping you avoid costly water damage. 

If you’re considering new gutters, you’ve likely encountered the two primary types: segmented (or sectional) gutters and extruded (or seamless) gutters. While segmented gutters are more affordable and DIY-friendly, extruded gutters offer superior durability and a sleek, seamless look. 

This guide explores the pros and cons of extruded gutters to help you determine if they’re the right fit for your home. 

What Exactly Are Extruded Gutters? 

Extruded gutters, also known as seamless gutters, are created using a specialized process. 

Molten metal—typically aluminum, copper, or steel—is pushed through a die to form a continuous, custom-fit gutter system with minimal seams. 

Why are fewer seams beneficial? Fewer seams mean a lower risk of leaks and clogs. 

Aluminum is the most popular choice for extruded gutters due to its rust resistance and lightweight nature, 

while copper provides a premium look that develops a beautiful patina over time. 

The Upsides of Extruded Gutters 

1. Built to Last: Extra Durable Extruded Gutters 

Made from robust materials like aluminum, extruded gutters resist rust, corrosion, and UV damage. 

Unlike vinyl, which can crack in extreme temperatures, aluminum remains durable for over 20 years with minimal maintenance. 

Opting for copper can extend the lifespan to over 50 years, adding long-term value to your home. 

2. Custom-Fit for Your Home 

Extruded gutters are cut to your roof’s precise measurements, making them ideal for homes with unique architectural features like curved eaves or steep pitches. 

Available in widths ranging from 5-inch to 7-inch and styles such as K-style or half-round, they seamlessly complement any home design. 

3. Fewer Leaks, Less Maintenance 

Segmented gutters feature joints every 10 to 20 feet, creating weak points that can leak or separate over time. 

In contrast, extruded gutters have minimal seams—typically only at corners and downspouts—reducing leaks and minimizing maintenance. 

4. Enhances Curb Appeal 

In addition to being practical, extruded gutters offer a clean, streamlined look that enhances your home’s exterior. 

With multiple color options available, you can match your gutters to your roof or trim for a polished, cohesive appearance. 

The Downsides of Extruded Gutters 

1. Higher Upfront Costs 

If you’re on a budget, note that extruded gutters cost between $8 to $12 per linear foot for installation, 

whereas segmented gutters range from $4 to $8 per foot. 

However, their durability and reduced maintenance often make them a more cost-effective long-term investment. 

2. Requires Professional Installation 

Unlike sectional gutters, extruded gutters are not a DIY project. 

Professional installation is necessary since the process involves specialized equipment. 

Improper installation can lead to sagging or drainage issues, so hiring experienced contractors is crucial. 

3. Limited Repair Flexibility 

If a section of an extruded gutter becomes damaged, replacing it can be more complex than swapping out a single section of a segmented gutter. 

In some cases, an entire segment may need to be replaced. 

FAQs About Gutter Types 

1. How long do extruded gutters last? 

• Aluminum extruded gutters: 20–30 years 

• Copper extruded gutters: 50+ years 

• Segmented gutters: 10–20 years 

2. Are extruded gutters worth the cost? 

Yes, in most cases. The decrease in leaks, reduced maintenance, and extended lifespan often justify the higher upfront cost. 

3. How do extruded gutters perform in extreme weather? 

They excel in areas with heavy rainfall or snow due to their seamless design and sturdy construction. 

Comparing Extruded vs. Segmented Gutters 

Final Thoughts 

With their unmatched durability, sleek appearance, and minimal leak potential, extruded gutters are a great choice for many homeowners. 

However, their higher cost and need for professional installation may not be ideal for everyone. 

By weighing factors like budget, home design, and local weather conditions, you can make an informed decision on the best gutter system for your needs. 

Take Action Today 

Thinking about upgrading your gutters? Maine Gutter Works offers expert installation, maintenance, and repair services. 

Contact us today for a complimentary estimate and protect your home with the best gutter solutions.